Anal stretching butt plug. Made out of premium silicone ayou can insert it the butt plug very deep and very easy. Nice stretching. Your anus gets stretched like never before and the sensation is unbelievable. There are two main types of sex toy that will help in this endeavour: Can it cause problems? The same rules apply, lots of lube, slow and steady, and stop if any pain occurs. Fox Tail Butt Plugs. Tail Butt Plugs. What is the best lubricant for a butt plug? How long do I need to do this for?